How to Run an RFP for a Higher Ed Marketing Partner

This is the third in a three-part series (part 1, part 2) on choosing a digital enrollment marketing partner, where we go into the vetting process and criteria that make up a standout higher ed and enrollment marketing partner.

Here are the questions to ask, the signals to watch, and a simple scorecard to help you pick the right partner.

This is the last post in our three-part series on choosing a higher ed marketing partner. In Part 1, we made the case that the right fit beats “the best.” In Part 2, we walked through what separates a real higher ed partner from a generalist.

Now, we put it into action by running an RFP or discovery meeting that gets you honest answers, what to watch for along the way, and a scorecard to compare your shortlist. This will give you better answers and a fairer, more realistic comparison.

Why do so many RFPs turn into price comparisons?

Because partners get asked big questions without much to go on. Can you do this? Can you do it faster? Can you do it for less? Without context, the easiest thing to compare is price. That’s a tough spot for everyone.

The best recommendations come from partners who understand your situation. The good news is that a little openness early on makes the whole process smoother and more predictable.

What should you share with partners up front?

Four things make the biggest difference:

  • Your goals, and how you got there. “We want X leads” or “Y% growth” is a good start. Share the enrollment numbers and history behind it, too. That’s how a partner can tell you whether the goal is realistic.
  • Your media budget. Without it, nobody can tell you whether your goal is doable. Even a rough range helps.
  • Where your brand stands today. A well-known school can lean on the name it already has, so the job is getting the program in front of the right people. A smaller school may need to build awareness and trust while it promotes the program. That difference shows up in your cost per lead.
  • How things work now. How connected are your website and digital marketing? How good is your analytics? Where do leads get handed off to admissions?

Sharing this early helps you avoid scope creep, shifting goals and budgets, and surprise changes after you’ve picked your shortlist. You’ll also quickly see which partners ask the right questions.

What questions should you ask a higher ed marketing partner?

These ten questions get past the pitch and show you how a partner really works:

  1. Which schools like ours (similar size, type, and programs) have you worked with in the last two years? Can we talk to one of them?
  2. What enrollment results did you get for your most similar client? For example, cost per enrolled student, yield, or how many inquiries turned into applications.
  3. Which CRMs and student information systems (SIS) have you worked with, and how do you get leads to our admissions team?
  4. How do you connect the website, paid media, content, and CRM so they work as one system instead of separate projects?
  5. How do you handle FERPA (the federal student privacy law) and student data privacy in your campaigns?
  6. How do you track what’s working when a student’s decision takes a year or more?
  7. Who exactly will work on our account, and what’s their higher ed experience?
  8. What happens if our enrollment goals or budget change partway through?
  9. What’s included in your standard scope, and what costs extra?
  10. How do you help schools show up accurately everywhere students look, including Google, social media, and AI tools like ChatGPT and Gemini?

That last question matters more every year. In OHO’s 2026 research, about 4 in 10 students ages 17–22 who were researching colleges said they use AI to do it.

What signals deserve a closer look?

Some partners promise the world. Others ask you to keep expectations realistic. None of these signals is a deal-breaker on its own, but each one is worth a follow-up question:

  • Case studies that stop at activity. “We drove millions of impressions,” but nothing about enrollment.
  • Compliance that only comes up when you bring it up.
  • One-size-fits-all packages that don’t flex for your type of school or mix of programs.
  • Senior people who vanish after the pitch, leaving most of the work to junior staff.
  • No clear way to measure results across long decisions with lots of touchpoints.
  • Pressure to sign fast, or long contracts with no room to adjust.
  • Trouble naming the CRM and SIS systems they’ve worked with.
  • Channel-by-channel thinking, with no clear answer for how the pieces fit together.

How do you compare partners side by side?

Use this quick scorecard. Rate each partner from 1 to 5 on every row (we cover each one in detail in [Part 2]([PART 2 URL])). Multiply each score by its weight: High = 3, Medium = 2, and Low to medium = 1. Then add up the totals and compare your shortlist.

Higher ed marketing partner evaluation scorecard. Rate each partner 1–5 per row, multiply by the weight (High = 3, Medium = 2, Low to medium = 1), and add up the total. Source: OHO.
CriteriaWeightWhat to look forScore (1–5)Weighted score
Proven higher ed results with similar schoolsHigh (×3)Real references, not just logos  
Connected strategy from first touch to enrollmentHigh (×3)How channels, website, and CRM work together  
CRM and SIS experienceHigh (×3)Slate, Salesforce, Element451, and others  
Compliance and data know-howHigh (×3)FERPA awareness and careful data handling  
Search and content know-how for .edu sitesMedium (×2)Search, social, reviews, and AI answers  
Paid media that fits your audiencesMedium (×2)Channels matched to the students you want  
Reporting that ties to enrollmentMedium (×2)Real outcomes, not vanity metrics  
Team structure and senior accessMedium (×2)Who actually works on your account  
Contract flexibilityLow to medium (×1)Room to adjust mid-cycle  
Cultural fitLow to medium (×1)How the sales process itself feels  
Total 

Frequently asked questions

What does a higher ed digital marketing agency actually do?

Usually some mix of SEO, paid search and social ads, content, email and CRM nurture campaigns, landing pages, website improvements, and analytics. The best partners connect all of it, so students move smoothly from first hearing about you to enrolling, and sometimes beyond.

How much does a higher ed marketing agency cost?

It depends a lot on your size, how many programs you’re marketing, and which channels you use. Retainers can run from a few thousand dollars a month for one program to six figures a year for bigger, multi-program campaigns. Ad spend is usually separate from management fees.

How long does it take to see results?

College decisions take a long time, so real enrollment impact often takes one to three full recruitment cycles. Early signs like website traffic and inquiries can move in the first few months, which gives you a quick read on how a program is doing.

Should we hire an agency or build an in-house team?

Lots of schools do both. Your team owns the brand, admissions relationships, and day-to-day content. A partner adds specialized skills, like paid media, technical SEO, or campaign strategy, during busy recruiting seasons or bigger projects. The right mix depends on your team’s time, budget, and skill gaps.

Should we hire a higher ed specialist or a general marketing agency?

A higher ed specialist usually gets up to speed faster on enrollment funnels, CRM and SIS systems, and compliance. That matters, because higher ed works very differently from selling to consumers or businesses. A strong general agency can work too, if it’s willing to learn your world. Just factor in the ramp-up time and the compliance risk.

The bottom line

There’s no single “best” higher ed marketing agency. There’s the partner that best fits your enrollment goals, your programs, your team, and your compliance needs. The right partner can also connect all the pieces into one smooth experience for students. That’s the idea we started this series with.

Only you and your team know what the right fit looks like. Use the questions and scorecard from this series to run a fair, structured search, instead of picking whoever tops a promotional “best agencies” list. The schools that get the most out of their partnerships treat this like any other important hire. They check references, ask how the work actually gets done, and look past the pitch deck.

Want a second set of eyes on your enrollment marketing approach? We’re always happy to talk it through.